If you’ve ever dipped a crispy chicken tender into that irresistibly tangy-sweet sauce at McAlister’s Deli, you know exactly how addictive their honey mustard truly is.
The good news? You don’t need to visit the restaurant to enjoy it anymore. This copycat McAlister honey mustard recipe brings that beloved condiment straight to your kitchen with simple ingredients you likely already have.
Whether you’re drizzling it over salads, dunking fries, or slathering it on sandwiches, this homemade honey mustard delivers the perfect balance of sweetness and tang that makes the original so crave-worthy.
What is McAlister Honey Mustard and How Does It Taste?
McAlister’s honey mustard is a creamy, restaurant-style condiment that perfectly balances sweet honey with tangy mustard flavors. This honey mustard recipe creates a smooth, velvety sauce that’s neither too sweet nor too sharp-just perfectly balanced.
The taste profile features the mellow creaminess from mayonnaise and sour cream, complemented by the distinctive bite of both yellow and Dijon mustards, all rounded out with natural honey sweetness and a bright citrus finish.
Unlike store-bought versions that can taste artificial or one-dimensional, this homemade honey mustard offers complex flavor layers that make it incredibly versatile. It’s the kind of sauce that transforms ordinary chicken nuggets into something special and elevates even the simplest sandwich into a gourmet experience.
McAlister’s Honey Mustard Recipe Ingredients and Kitchen Utensils
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
- 2 tablespoons sour cream
- 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
- 2 tablespoons yellow mustard (regular American-style mustard)
- 2 tablespoons honey (add more if you prefer it sweeter)
- 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice (or substitute with distilled white vinegar for a sharper tang)
Kitchen Utensils
- Medium mixing bowl
- Whisk, fork, or spoon
- Measuring spoons
- Airtight container for storage
Preparation and Cooking Time
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Servings: Makes approximately ½ cup (enough for 4-6 servings)
Copycat McAlister’s Honey Mustard Recipe
Step 1: Gather all your ingredients and place them within easy reach. Add the mayonnaise, sour cream, Dijon mustard, yellow mustard, honey, and fresh lemon juice to a medium mixing bowl.
Step 2: Using a whisk, fork, or spoon, stir all the ingredients together vigorously. Continue mixing for 30–60 seconds until the honey mustard with yellow mustard becomes completely smooth, creamy, and well blended with no streaks remaining.
Step 3: Taste your McAlister honey mustard and adjust the flavor to your preference. Add additional honey one teaspoon at a time for extra sweetness, more lemon juice or vinegar for added brightness, or a pinch of salt to enhance overall flavor.
Step 4: Your sauce is now ready to serve immediately as a dipping sauce, sandwich spread, or salad dressing. Alternatively, transfer it to an airtight container and refrigerate. The honey mustard recipe without dijon alternative works too-simply double the yellow mustard amount. Store in the refrigerator for up to 1 week, stirring before each use as it may thicken slightly when chilled.
Customization and Pairing Ideas for Serving
1. Spicy Kick Variation
Transform your copycat McAlister honey mustard recipe by adding ½ teaspoon of hot sauce, a pinch of cayenne pepper, or a dash of sriracha. This creates a sweet-heat combination that’s perfect for those who love a little fire with their flavor.
2. Herbed Honey Mustard
Elevate this homemade honey mustard by stirring in ½ teaspoon of dried herbs like dill, tarragon, or Italian seasoning. Fresh minced herbs like parsley or chives add wonderful color and fresh flavor notes that complement grilled chicken or fish beautifully.
3. Garlic Lover’s Version
Mix in ½ teaspoon of garlic powder or one minced fresh garlic clove to create a savory depth that makes this sauce exceptional on roast beef sandwiches or as a marinade base for grilled meats.
4. Classic Chicken Tender Pairing
Serve your McAlister honey mustard alongside crispy chicken tenders, nuggets, or fried chicken strips for the ultimate comfort food experience that rivals any restaurant offering.
5. Salad Dressing Application
Thin out this honey mustard recipe with 1-2 tablespoons of olive oil or additional lemon juice to create a restaurant-quality salad dressing that’s perfect for chicken salads, wedge salads, or mixed green salads.
6. Sandwich and Wrap Spread
Use this honey mustard with yellow mustard as a flavorful spread on turkey clubs, ham and cheese sandwiches, grilled chicken wraps, or even as a unique twist on your burger condiments.
7. Pretzel and Vegetable Dip
Serve this creamy sauce as a dipping companion for soft pretzels, pretzel bites, fresh vegetable crudités, or crispy potato wedges at your next gathering or game day party.
Essential Tips for Perfect Honey Mustard
1. Room Temperature Ingredients
Allow your mayonnaise and sour cream to sit at room temperature for 15-20 minutes before mixing. This simple step ensures smoother blending and creates a more velvety texture in your copycat McAlister honey mustard recipe without any lumps or separation.
2. Honey Consistency Matters
If your honey has crystallized or is very thick, warm it gently in the microwave for 5-10 seconds before adding it to your homemade honey mustard. This makes mixing easier and ensures even distribution throughout the sauce.
3. Mustard Balance is Key
The combination of Dijon and yellow mustard creates the signature flavor profile. If you’re making a honey mustard recipe without dijon, double the yellow mustard amount but note that the flavor will be milder and less complex than the original version.
4. Adjust Sweetness Gradually
When learning how to make honey mustard with yellow mustard, always add extra honey in small increments-about ½ teaspoon at a time. It’s much easier to add sweetness than to correct an overly sweet sauce later.
5. Vinegar vs. Lemon Juice
While fresh lemon juice provides a brighter, more citrusy flavor, distilled white vinegar creates a sharper, more traditional mustard tang. Experiment with both to find your preferred flavor profile for this McAlister honey mustard recreation.
6. Proper Storage Technique
Always store your honey mustard recipe in a clean, airtight container in the refrigerator. Glass jars work exceptionally well. Before each use, give the container a good shake or stir, as natural separation may occur during storage.
7. Make-Ahead Convenience
This honey mustard with yellow mustard actually tastes better after resting in the refrigerator for 2-4 hours, as the flavors meld and develop. Make it the night before your gathering for optimal taste and to save time on busy days.
Storage and Reheating Guidance
Store your homemade honey mustard in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to one week. No reheating is necessary-simply remove from the fridge 5 minutes before serving and stir well, as the sauce may thicken when chilled.
McAlister Honey Mustard Recipe
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Gather all your ingredients and place them within easy reach. Add the mayonnaise, sour cream, Dijon mustard, yellow mustard, honey, and fresh lemon juice to a medium mixing bowl.
- Using a whisk, fork, or spoon, stir all the ingredients together vigorously. Continue mixing for 30–60 seconds until the honey mustard with yellow mustard becomes completely smooth, creamy, and well blended with no streaks remaining.
- Taste your McAlister honey mustard and adjust the flavor to your preference. Add additional honey one teaspoon at a time for extra sweetness, more lemon juice or vinegar for added brightness, or a pinch of salt to enhance overall flavor.
- Your sauce is now ready to serve immediately as a dipping sauce, sandwich spread, or salad dressing. Alternatively, transfer it to an airtight container and refrigerate. The honey mustard recipe without dijon alternative works too-simply double the yellow mustard amount. Store in the refrigerator for up to 1 week, stirring before each use as it may thicken slightly when chilled.
Video
Notes
Common Queries and FAQs
Here, we’ve got you covered with some common questions about the McAlister Honey Mustard Recipe that people often ask.
Q: Can I make this honey mustard recipe without Dijon mustard?
A: Yes! For a honey mustard recipe without dijon, simply use 4 tablespoons of yellow mustard total instead. The flavor will be milder and less complex, but still delicious and creamy.
Q: How long does homemade honey mustard last?
A: When properly stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, this McAlister honey mustard recipe stays fresh for up to 7 days. Always check for any off odors before using.
Q: Can I substitute Greek yogurt for sour cream?
A: Absolutely! Plain Greek yogurt works wonderfully in this copycat McAlister honey mustard recipe and adds extra protein while reducing calories. The texture remains creamy and delicious.
Q: Why is my honey mustard too thick?
A: If your homemade honey mustard is thicker than desired, thin it by whisking in water, lemon juice, or vinegar one teaspoon at a time until you reach your preferred consistency.
Q: Can I use brown mustard instead of yellow mustard?
A: Yes, though the flavor will be slightly different. Brown mustard has a spicier, more robust flavor than standard yellow mustard, which will change the overall taste profile of your honey mustard with yellow mustard.
Q: Is this recipe good for meal prep?
A: Definitely! This honey mustard recipe is perfect for meal prep. Make a batch on Sunday to use throughout the week on sandwiches, salads, and as a dipping sauce for proteins.
Q: Can I double or triple this recipe?
A: Yes! This McAlister honey mustard recipe scales beautifully. Just maintain the same ingredient ratios, and you can easily make larger batches for parties or gatherings.
This copycat McAlister honey mustard recipe proves that restaurant-quality condiments are surprisingly easy to recreate at home. With just six simple ingredients and five minutes of your time, you can enjoy the same tangy-sweet sauce you love from McAlister’s Deli whenever a craving strikes.
The beauty of making your own homemade honey mustard lies in the customization-adjust the sweetness, tanginess, or add your own creative twists. Once you experience how simple how to make honey mustard with yellow mustard truly is, you’ll never go back to store-bought versions. Mix up a batch today and discover your new favorite condiment!
Feel free to share your experience with this recipe by trying it out. Don’t forget to drop a comment and provide your feedback on the blog for us to read.
Be sure to follow CopyCat Cooking on Pinterest and YouTube for more delicious recipe inspiration. Your support and feedback mean everything to us!